Dear Tess and Stu, I think we all reacted to Catherine’s message in the same way.
I realized, after I had written my message, that Catherine’s user name is Resentment. I feel so very sorry for Catherine because of her attitude, but even more sorry for her husband.
Tess, you are absolutely right about a positive sentence being interpreted very differently by a group of people. A psychologist once replied to a letter I had written. He complimented me on my writing and I took this in the spirit it was intended. However, a friend could not have been angrier when she read the letter. ‘How patronizing!’ she declared ‘Why shouldn’t you write well, who does he think he is, pointing that out to you?!’
Catherine’s message is more difficult to view in a different light, however. In a previous message, she spoke of shame and I found this most distressing. Catherine stated “ I feel ashamed to let my family and friends into my life and our home for fear that my husband's shameful secret might be revealed, which would only make my husband feel worse.”
Catherine, I urge you to take Tess’ advice and find out more about this illness. No-one should feel ashamed of it or refer to it as a ‘shameful secret‘. Your husband should not feel the need to hide his illness.
Also, I feel it is very upsetting to imply that only God knows what we deserve. There is so much suffering, even amongst innocent babies and young children. None of whom deserves such pain. The reasons, for those of us who are religious, remain a mystery. However, although I am a Christian, I find some other religions’ theories make more sense over such matters.
I think the greatest message from any religion is love, compassion and tolerance.